• Valentine's Day

    Tuesday Feb 14th!
    Regular Menu Served All Day

    Make A Reservation Here
  • King Crab Knuckles

    Frozen To Take Home or Steamed Dine In
    $19.99 Lb.

  • Local Sea Scallops

    Now in stock!!!
    While supplies last!

    Follow us on Instagram
  • Fresh Cod Loins

    In Stock All Season!

    Follow Us On Instagram
  • Local Fried Oysters

    Served with a lemon aioli, french fries & coleslaw!

    Follow Us On Instagram
Seafood Restaurants Port Jefferson, NY

The Freshest Seafood Restaurant in Suffolk County, NY

When it comes to seafood restaurants in New York’s Suffolk County, PJ Lobster House Restaurant and Fish Market has become a local favorite. Having proudly served the 
Port Jefferson, NY community since 1995, we specialize in the preparation of live lobsters – with stock sizes up to 3 lbs.!

Our full service casual dining room can seat up to 100 guests for dinner or for your special occasion. Come down and watch the local games on our plasma TVs and come see where the locals eat! Free Wifi available for those that need to get work done while enjoying a great meal!

Your Local Seafood Restaurant and Fish Market

We’re more than a seafood restaurant, we also feature an onsite fresh fish market. Our fresh fish market receives deliveries seven days a week, ensuring that we have the highest-quality, freshest selection around! We support the local fishing industry by purchasing directly from the Long Island Sound commercial fisherman and diggers whenever available.

Stop in and try some craft beers now on tap:
New Belgium Fat Tire
Blue Moon Belgian Ale
Captain Lawrence Captain's Reserve Imperial IPA
Brooklyn Sorachi Ace Saison
New Belgium Pilsener
Port Jeff Orange Dream
Montauk Session IPA
Montauk Wave Chaser IPA
Montauk Arrowhead Red Ale
Bluepoint Toasted Lager
Guinness Stout
Saranac Root Beer (Non Alcoholic)
Happy Hour Setauket, NY
We love to hear your feedback... so let us know!

Contact Us

Sundays Dinner For Two
Price Fixed Special $53
Includes: Two Soups or Salads, 
One Appetizer to Share, Two Entrees, 
and One Dessert to Share
Regular Menu Also Available

Monday Happy Hour
Discounted Beers & Appetizers
Served 3:00 - 6:00

Tuesday Nights 
All You Can Eat Snow Crab Legs $39.99 
Includes Soup or House Salad & Two Sides
Served 4:00 - 9:30

Wednesday Nights
All You Can Eat Shrimp $24.99
Includes Soup or House Salad & Two Sides
Served 4:00 - 9:30

Thursday Nights
Lobster Fest $24.99
1- ¼ lb. Lobster, Mussels, Corn, Potato,
and a House Salad

Friday Happy Hour
Discounted Beers & Appetizers
Served 3:00 - 6:00

Hours of Operations

Share by: